Mendeleev's Periodic Table: Achievements and Limitations



 

Even after the rejection of Newlands� Law of Octaves, many scientists continued to search for a pattern that correlated the properties of elements with their atomic masses. The main credit for classifying elements goes to Dmitri Ivanovich Mendel�ev, a Russian chemist.

He was the most important contributor to the early development of a Periodic Table of elements wherein the elements were arranged on the basis of their fundamental property, the atomic mass, and also on the similarity of chemical properties.

 

When Mendel�ev started his work, 63 elements were known. He examined the relationship between the atomic masses of the elements and their physical and chemical properties. Among chemical properties, Mendel�ev concentrated on the compounds formed by elements with oxygen and hydrogen.

 

He selected hydrogen and oxygen as they are very reactive and formed compounds with most elements. The formulae of the hydrides and oxides formed by an element were treated as one of the basic properties of an element for its classification.

 

He then took 63 cards and on each card he wrote down the properties of one element. He sorted out the elements with similar properties and pinned the cards together on a wall. He observed that most of the elements got a place in a Periodic Table and were arranged in the order of their increasing atomic masses. It was also observed that there occurs a periodic recurrence of elements with similar physical and chemical properties.

 

On this basis, Mendel�ev formulated a Periodic Law, which states that �the properties of elements are the periodic function of their atomic masses. Mendel�ev�s Periodic Table contains vertical columns called �groups� and horizontal rows called �periods.

 

Achievements of Mendel�ev�s Periodic Table

 

While developing the Periodic Table, there were a few instances where Mendel�ev had to place an element with a slightly greater atomic mass before an element with a slightly lower atomic mass. The sequence was inverted so that elements with similar properties could be grouped together. For example, cobalt (atomic mass 58.9) appeared before nickel (atomic mass 58.7).

 

Further, Mendel�ev left some gaps in his Periodic Table.

 

Instead of looking upon these gaps as defects, Mendel�ev boldly predicted the existence of some elements that had not been discovered at that time. Mendel�ev named them by prefixing a Sanskrit numeral, Eka(one) to the name of the preceding element in the same group.

 

For instance, scandium, gallium and germanium, discovered later, have properties similar to Eka�boron, Eka�aluminum and Eka�silicon, respectively. The properties of Eka�Aluminium predicted by Mendel�ev and those of the element, gallium which was discovered later and replaced Ekaaluminium, are listed as follows

 

This provided convincing evidence for both the correctness and usefulness of Mendel�ev�s Periodic Table.

 

Further, it was the extraordinary success of Mendel�ev�s prediction that led chemists not only to accept his Periodic Table but also recognize him, as the originator of the concept on which it is based. Noble gases like helium (He), neon (Ne), and argon (Ar) have been mentioned in many a context before this.

 

These gases were discovered very late because they are very inert and present in extremely low concentrations in our atmosphere. One of the strengths of Mendel�ev�s Periodic Table was that, when these gases were discovered, they could be placed in a new group without disturbing the existing order.

 

Limitation of Mendeleev Classification

 

The electronic configuration of hydrogen resembles that of alkali metals. Like alkali metals, hydrogen combines with halogens, oxygen, and sulfur to form compounds having similar formulae, as shown in the examples here.

 

On the other hand, just like halogens, hydrogen also exists as diatomic molecules and it combines with metals and non-metals to form covalent compounds. Certainly, no fixed position can be given to hydrogen in the Periodic Table. This was the first limitation of Mendel�ev�s Periodic Table.

 

He could not assign a correct position to hydrogen in his Table. Isotopes were discovered long after Mendel�ev had proposed his periodic classification of elements. Let us recall that isotopes of an element have similar chemical properties, but different atomic masses

 

Thus, isotopes of all elements posed a challenge to Mendeleev�s Periodic Law. Another problem was that the atomic masses do not increase in a regular manner in going from one element to the next. So it was not possible to predict how many elements could be discovered between two elements � especially when we consider the heavier elements.

Read More: Periodic Classification Of Elements - Trends in Modern Periodic Table

 

Leave your comment

Open chat